Review by Frank Plowright
Perhaps not to such a great degree, but long before Jar Jar Binks, the opinions of Star Wars fans differed about C-3PO and his fussy and cautious nature, and he frequently features in online lists of the less iconic characters. The conundrum is that the far more likeable R2D2 doesn’t work nearly as well without him, C-3PO being needed to translate the electronic beeps that pass for R2’s communication. In the original films the buddy relationship just about passes muster, but thrusting the pair into a never intended spotlight really reveals the shortcomings of C-3PO. He has to carry much of the three longer stories here, and his personality’s just not suited to it.
Dan Thorsland’s original solution over the course of ‘The Kalarba Adventures’ is to aim the plot squarely at a younger audience, creating an incompetent “Why I oughtta…” villain and landing the droids with a family, enabling sitcom moments. It’s only when Thorsland moves away from that over the final chapters that the content improves. Bill Hughes (sample art left) pitches his art at a level matching the plot, but varying his style for a short Ryder Windham piece reveals a far better artist, and that’s seen on the later ‘Season of Revolt’ in which his designs and layouts carry another predictable story. This is the work of Jan Strnad who mixes C-3PO and R2D2 with a well meaning Ithorian guarding a secret, a ruthless dictator and a substance that only needs a single small dose to transform humans into a state of perpetual bliss. There are funny moments, but not enough of them.
Windham and Ian Gibson serve up the best longer piece, concerning a robot revolt in ‘Rebellion’, with Gibson in familiar territory, joyfully reprising his work on similar stories for 2000AD. His loose lines and intricate designs accentuate a fun plot in which Windham applies a greater imagination than the other writers, solving the problem of C-3PO’s personality not being designed to carry a story. Windham also makes good use of previously introduced characters as the droids become involved in a robot rebellion.
‘The Protocol Offensive’ wasn’t available with the earlier collections. It’s co-scripted by Windham with Anthony Daniels, who played C-3PO in the movies, from Brian Daley’s plot, and plays to the droids strength by featuring them having to use translation and protocol skills in very delicate negotiations. The words overflow, but points are well made, it entertains and has the benefit of some fantastic Igor Kordey art (sample page). Kordey draws on Gerry Anderson models for spacecraft, and uses a similar bright colour scheme to that applied to comics based on Anderson’s work in the 1960s. It’s distinctive and appealing. Anyone who enjoys figuring out mysteries will be drawn to one character as the guilty party, and so they are, but this is step up from the remainder of the content.
This Omnibus is now out of print, although used copies are easily found, as they are if you’d prefer the individual segments. It’s been replaced by Marvel Epic Collection: Star Wars Legends – The Empire Vol. 5, which has the space for a couple of extra stories, although not featuring droids.