Review by Frank Plowright
Reviewing Elon Musk American Oligarch in the week it was revealed he reputedly spent half a billion dollars to influence the outcome of the 2026 US mid-term elections is somehow apt. It’s a reminder that no matter how much power and money some people have, their will falters in the face of democracy. Darryl Cunningham’s exhaustive undertaking reminds us how frequently Musk courts those with no democratic principles. It all seems to be in the service of the world’s richest man acquiring even greater personal wealth.
Notably published in France before an English language edition, Cunningham is scrupulous in his use of sourced material, but builds a picture of a self-serving and not very likeable man from a difficult upbringing to his current status. Musk posts so much daft stuff on Twitter and plays up to his perceived persona as a James Bond-style global villain that it’s easy to forget he’s a pretty smart guy, although crucially, not as smart as he’d have you believe. While he’s not always personally seen his ideas through, he has them in the first place, although Cunningham reveals he’ll make statements about an intention as actuality and then attempt to engineer a product living up to the statement.
Cunningham adheres to the format of his previous fact-based books by illustrating small, neat panels, mostly at six to a page. He begins by relating the story of Musk’s grandfather Joshua Haldeman, a remarkable man with odious personal views who transplanted his family to South Africa in 1950 partly because he agreed with the country’s apartheid policies. Moving to the young Musk, we’re shown him blessed with a fine memory and that he’s always been a grafter, conceiving ideas in childhood that if not the basis of his current fortune, certainly put him on the way toward it. There’s something to be admired in a teenager having the wherewithall to almost pull off owning a video arcade.
Ambition apart, Cunningham doesn’t show much to be admired about Musk the eventual businessman. He transmits as one of those single-minded people that everyone eventually falls out with, be they business partner, wife or child. Most tellingly, toward the end Cunningham sets about dismantling some myths. Musk’s brief 2025 spell as a government official under Donald Trump was characterised by a desire to cut public spending, yet Cunningham shows that without public money Musk’s businesses wouldn’t have survived. It doesn’t play well into the legend of self-made genius. Neither does the actual vital work carried out by people who oversaw the engineering of later successful projects.
A controversial notion not often highlighted drives Musk’s space projects and the tremendous amounts of money they cost. Could that money be better spent solving problems in the here and now rather than funding the belief that if humanity is to survive the species must eventually leave Earth?
Because everything about Elon Musk American Oligarch is sourced from other publications and speculation is minimal there’s no new material here, but Cunningham arranges his research in very transmissible form. The result supplies as good an insight into Musk as we’re likely to get.