Review by Ian Keogh

Although this follows The Big No-No in publication order, there’s no continuity to the Benny and Penny books, which can be read in any order.

After an absence last time, it’s nice to see Benny back in his pirate hat, just because Geoffrey Hayes draws it so charmingly, and for the first time the series introduces a raised level of conflict from The Big No-No. Bullying is the theme as cousin Bo comes to visit, inducing a feeling of dread in Benny and Penny who immediately hide all their toys. Bo has no consideration for the possessions of others, and has broken their toys in the past. The lack of consideration extends to feelings also. While Hayes never has him become too violent, Bo taunts Benny and Penny by asking if they’re going to cry for mummy every time he does something mean.

The level of conflict is set just above annoyance, with Bo shown to have feelings himself, the implication being that he doesn’t receive the proper guidance. That’s unstated, though, as Hayes wants to set an example, and eventually has the children sorting out their differences without adult intervention. It straddles a fine line, as while Hayes ensures it’s not obvious to children, the Benny and Penny books are instructional, and there will always be some kids you can’t get along with and the involvement of a responsible adult will be required.

That qualm aside, this is another engaging story for young readers, beautifully drawn and recapturing the innocent enjoyment of childhood. Lights Out is next in the series.