Review by Frank Plowright
Credit to publishers Rebellion for continuing The Rise and Fall of the Trigan Empire to encompass the entire series as originally serialised, but this being an edition limited to 400 copies indicates an awareness of these final stories from 1980 to 1982 not being the quality anyone associates with the title. Don’t get too excited by seeing the names of original creators Mike Butterworth and Don Lawrence in the credits, as their sole contribution is a six page text story with six admittedly great accompanying illustrations from Lawrence dating from 1976.
The remaining content is provided by Ken Roscoe and Gerry Wood. Volume VI showed Roscoe’s preference for running stories around double the length of the classic material, and that continues. Quantity isn’t quality, though, and while now serviceable, Roscoe’s plots remain distant echoes rehashing past glories. Some credit is due for his at least mentioning the Trigans as colonialists in opening story ‘The Zabriz Conspiracy’, and slave revolts form the basis of a couple of stories, but in presenting the leaders as villains, Roscoe rather undermines any sympathy for their valid grievances. He also scores for returning women to the series, initially Trigo’s long-forgotten wife Ursa, then scientist Peric’s daughter Salvia. Unfortunately, though, they’re both used as hostages.
Wood’s art is a crude approximation of Lawrence’s earlier pages, best when moving away from people toward monsters and spacecraft, where the stiffness of the poses isn’t as apparent. There’s never any inclination toward the spectacular with Wood, and the basic nature of the painting sucks the thrills from Roscoe’s better plots.
A puzzling, yet common technique Roscoe uses is ignoring the main cast. In many stories he concentrates instead on events that set a plot in motion rather than beginning with the Trigans reacting to a threat, and eccentrically he sidelines most of the main cast for ‘Search Mission’. Instead it stars Peric’s previously unknown son Fidelius, a member of the Tharv Guard, although Trigo’s nephew Janno comes to the rescue.
Better choices of artists after Lawrence might have meant the material following his departure was held in higher regard. It leaves this volume as something for completists rather than purists. Oh, and the series title proves somewhat the misnomer as we never see the fall of the Trigan Empire.