Star Trek: Lower Decks – Second Second Contact

Artist
Writer
RATING:
Star Trek: Lower Decks – Second Second Contact
Star Trek Lower Decks Second Second Contact review
SAMPLE IMAGE 
SAMPLE IMAGE 
  • NORTH AMERICAN PUBLISHER / ISBN: IDW - 979-8-88724-502-7
  • VOLUME NO.: 3
  • RELEASE DATE: 2026
  • UPC: 9798887245027
  • CONTAINS ADULT CONTENT?: no
  • DOES THIS PASS THE BECHDEL TEST?: yes
  • POSITIVE MINORITY PORTRAYAL?: yes

Should this technically be titled Third Contact or does Second Second Contact work for you, seeing as it follows Second Contact?

You’ll be expecting more of the same quality comedy hijinks, and you’ll get it, but from a new creative team. Thankfully Tim Sheridan and Vernon Smith keep the standards high and the comedy going. They even make sense of the title, as the main plot concerns a second visit to Laapeeria, except the Laapeerians seem to have disappeared, complicating the entire contact process.

The good thing is that there’s another race prepared to help in the search, while the bad news is the presence of a previously unknown intimidating spacecraft chasing the Cerritos.

Sheridan delivers the same quirky characters and quickfire humour supplied by the TV show, and while it seems at first as if the top deck crew are being prioritised, Sheridan ensures everyone has a part to play. As things progress you’ll be happy to see a number of guest stars as well. A marker of a decent comedy plot is whether all the humour could be sifted out and the plot would still work, and that’s the case for Second Second Contact, except when it doesn’t, but we’ll get to that.

That’s only half of what you want, though, right? Well, rest assured Smith has the crew looking like they are on your TV screens, and that applies to his cartoon versions of characters more usually seen in live action.

So with all that going for it, why the comparatively low ranking? It’s because Sheridan eventually hasn’t got anywhere for the plot to go, and just gives up, actually inviting angry complaints. It’s supposed to be another joke, but fans deserve better, and editor Cassandra Jones shouldn’t have let him away with it.

Loading...